Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The meantone temperament was effective while the number of keys in use was limited. Interest in this tuning system goes back to the sixteenth century, when composer guillaume. My own opinon, to turn back to meantone, is that history is the best source for us. So, all the modern pianos you have ever heard are in one of the many types of meantone temperament. This book is welcome, aiming as it does to combine the historical, theoretical. To compare different tuning systems we will use cents. Even though d minor along with c major is typically the home key for regular meantone layouts, here is a simple proof by example that bach couldnt have intended such a regular layout for the inventionssinfonias. Under the old tuning, an organ made harmonious and attractive music. These four major patterns are referred to as temperaments. In making his own formulation of a temperament, kelletat gave strong credence to bachs pupil kirnberger.
You will notice the striking character of some of the chords. They cover a period of roughly 1500 1850, and are based mostly on practical tuning instructions of that time, from italy, france, germany and england. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the early music. Here dr david pitches experiments with a piece by krebs in meantone and equal temperament on the o. Historical tuning of keyboard instruments and why bach used well. In meantone temperament, this effect is even more pronounced the fifth over the break in the circle is known as the wolf interval, as its intense beating was likened to a howling. Listen to a minor second in equal temperament help info. E9 meantone, ji, et, a book i read about temperament. History of temperament and temperament theory tradition has it that fat men are jolly and generous, that lean men are dour, that short men are aggressive, and that strong men are silent and confident. The demands of tuning attaining the perfect scale and temperament the compromises necessary for composing in every key have challenged musicians from the earliest civilizations onward. Listening to the prelude in a flat major bwv 862 by j. This temperament is easy to explain and to tune, but it leaves a lot of the notes of the scale in quite odd positions. Dec 14, 2008 f minor was known to be able to express the darkest grief. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no kindle device required.
Bach played using the meantone temperament makes the problem evident to our ears. Over the past 2000 years temperament has changed, from region to region, from musician to musician, from year to year. The doctrine of temperament can be traced to the theory of humors which is a microcosmic form of the macrocosmic theory of the four elements earth, water, air, fire as first proposed by empedocles v b. The history of musical temperament and pitch before 1750.
It is thought to have first started in france in the last quarter of the 17th century in keyboard instruments. In the year 1496 franchino gafurio referred to the use of tempered fif on the organ. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the early music institute kindle edition by dolata, david. It is also called the diatonic semitone because it occurs between steps in the diatonic scale. Jun 14, 2018 this is bachs prelude from the anna magdalena book. J murray barbour the demands of tuning attaining the perfect scale and temperament the compromises necessary for composing in every key have challenged musicians from the earliest civilizations onward. Other scholars believe that the term well temperament was used in the eighteenth century to describe temperament in which all keys were usable and in which the main consonances of the most central keys kept their just forms. This means the ratio of the frequencies of any adjacent pair of notes is the same, which gives an equal perceived step size as pitch is perceived roughly as the logarithm of frequency. Murray barbours book, tuning and temperament a historical survey. The problem is related to the meantone fifth that is smaller than the acoustic fifth. Having discovered the joys of meantone temperament, physicist reinhardt.
Humoral theory states that there are four body humors, and their proper mixture is the condition of health. The use of 53 equal temperament provides a solution for the pythagorean tuning, and 31 equal temperament for the meantone. Some of these tunings, also known as temperaments, sound very well on renaissance lutes. Keyboards were tuned so that the major third would be. Sturgeons law applies, but then it applies to books as well. The resulting temperament has been absent from our history books. Written for musicians by a musician, meantone temperaments on lutes and viols demystifies tuning systems by providing the basic information, historical context, and practical advice necessary to easily achieve more satisfying tuning results on fretted instruments. Meantone and temperament in bachs time adapted by ben chi from a posting by daniel pyle writing to piporgl, paul west said. When welltemperaments appeared, meantone ones became the old method of tuning and these ones were simply referred to as the new method of tuning. In music, 19 equal temperament, called 19tet, 19edo, or 19et, is the scale derived by dividing the octave into 19 equally large steps. Meantone is the base of western harmony and all the common practice progressions and was abandoned when mass production of pianos made meantone not optimal for commercial products. Meantone temperament, 97862843753, please note that the content of this book primarily consists of articles available from wikipedia or. Meantone temperame nt is a musi cal temperam ent, that is a tuning system, obtained by slightly compromising the fifths in order to improve the th irds. Ive been tuning meantone, approx 16 comma, for a coons age.
This book is welcome, aiming as it does to combine the historical, theoretical, and practical aspects of this sometimes vexed and controversial. The result of this procedure is a scale with 8 pure major 3rds and 4. Written for musicians by a musician, meantone temperaments on lutes and. Meantone temperaments are constructed the same way as pythagorean tuning, as a stack of equal fifths, but in meantone each fifth is narrow compared to the perfect fifth of ratio 3. Their solution, laid out by pietro aron in the early 16th century, and referred to as meantone temperament or quartercomma meantone temperament, was to temper the interval of a perfect fifth slightly narrower than in just intonation, and then proceed much like pythagorean tuning, but using this tempered fifth instead of the just one. History of tuning and temperament ii greek tunings. A meantone tuning is any modification of just tuning in which all pitches in a scale. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. In meantone, all but one of the fifths are flattened from the pure 3. Meantone tuning appeared sometime around the late 15th. Because it enables keyboard instruments to play in all keys with minimal flaws in intonation, equal temperament replaced earlier tuning systems that were based on acoustically pure intervals.
The change to equal temperament happened at different times in different countries. History of music to 1750 the history of musical temperament and pitch before 1750 to most musicians, the idea that the sound of notes has changed is a foreign concept. An introduction to historical tunings by kyle gann 1. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the early music institute. Strictly, the term refers to an interval produced by a specific tuning system, widely used in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. By the early 17th century meantone temperament was the norm.
Meantone temperament is a musical temperament, that is a tuning system, obtained by slightly compromising the fifths in order to improve the thirds. Tuning and temperaments in the renaissance part i youtube. Admittedly, a few significant related topics are hardly covered in the book such as the documented baroque practice of fretting and playing in meantone and circular temperaments, and for these the musician has to read more recent publications. Fifteenthcentury evidence for meantone temperament jstor. In the perfect and deceptive cadences it appears as a resolution of the leadingtone to the tonic. The unequal temperaments book of 1978 was describedin writingas the definitive reference on the matter by authorities such as john barnes, hubert bedard, kenneth gilbert, igor kipnis, rudolf rasch and others. Featured texts all books all texts latest this just in smithsonian libraries fedlink us genealogy lincoln collection. Even though each tuner tuned differently, the principles were the same. Actuallyprovided the file is not shared with other readerscopying it is good practice, because a computer file may accidentally become corrupted or deleted. Organized chronologically, the book features a helpful glossary and numerous illustrative tables, and it. The minor second occurs in the major scale, between the third and fourth degree, mi e and fa f in c major, and between the seventh and eighth degree ti b and do c in c major. For a very complete list of historical temperaments, see the book by owen jorgensen listed at the bottom of this page. In the 1990s i also developed the first professionalgrade temperament spreadsheets. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols by david dolata.
Anyway, how equal temperament ruined harmony is probably about meantone, not about pythagorean. Meantone temperament, system of tuning keyboard instruments, most prevalent from the early 16th century through the 18th century. As explained at pp1656 of le temperament musical by dominique devie, herbert kelletat in 1960 started the speculation about bachs temperaments with the book zur musikalischen temperatur, i. It is quite satisfactory for music written in the old modes that preceded the major and minor scales, provided there is no modulation whatever. As explained at pp1656 of le temperament musical by dominique devie, herbert kelletat in 1960 started the speculation about bachs temperament s with the book zur musikalischen temperatur, i. A bizarre fact is that equal temperament is really meantone by 112th comma, that is every fifth is narrowed by 112 of the syntonic comma and the interval between c d and between d e are equal. It is also called the schismic temperament, helmholtz temperament, or quasipythagorean temperament. The various kinds of meantone and well temperament help explain why, in the 18 th into 19 th centuries, keys had particular emotional associations.
Equal temperament has smaller fifths than the harmonic series but they are closer 2 cents than the meantone 5 fifth or the well temperament reduced fifths 6 the following chart compares the tuning systems discussed with equal temperament horizontal line on the 0. Music reference services quarterly this book handles a difcult subject with clarity and vigor, and i imagine it willnd a welcome place on the bookshelf of the serious student interested in exploring the unique soundscape attainable only through meantone temperament. Each step represents a frequency ratio of the 19th root of 2, or 63. Equal temperament is the only practical temperament for the modern piano. Summary of equaltemperament, meantone, and welltemperament systems. Click on any one of these temperaments to download the temperament file. All through music history several systems of tuning were used. How then, can this little book a translation of the authors german version. Meantone temperament was oriented around major thirds a musical interval, such as ce, covering four semitones. An equal temperament is a musical temperament or tuning system, which approximates just intervals by dividing an octave or other interval into equal steps. As soon as he comes to understand the position of a particle, he cannot measure its velocity. In music theory, the wolf fifth sometimes also called procrustean fifth, or imperfect fifth is a particularly dissonant musical interval spanning seven semitones.
It was lost under layers of assumptions and habits that have led away from it. Organized chronologically, the book features a helpful glossary and numerous illustrative tables, and it requires minimal background in music theory. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the early music institute. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the. Meantone temperament for lute the examples in this article are for a renaissance lute in g. A clear and practical introduction to temperament history a series of nine articles by fred sturm, published in the piano technicians journal in 20102011. I submit for your consideration an oddly named book lying on an ordinary desk. The meantone temperament which paul describes, by 14 comma, was first writtenup just after 1500 by pietro aron, and is the best known. Meantone intonation is based on the philosophy that wayoutoftune thirds are more unpleasant than slightlyoutoftune fifths, so it sacrifices some of.
Jan 01, 2004 this guide surveys these longstanding problems, devoting a chapter to each principal theory and offering a running account of the complete history of tuning and temperament. Pythagoras is credited with inventing the pythagorean temperament at around 550 bc, in which the chromatic scale is generated by tuning in perfect. Meantone temperament is a musical temperament, that is a tuning system, obtained by slightly. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of. I believe that the particular sound of this temperament, as an integrated part of musical practice, has profound implications for all of bachs instrumental and vocal music that uses keyboards. Linda berens continues to expand our understanding of the four temperaments through the unique contributions. If the text of the temperament file just appears on the screen of your browser, then select save as in your browser to save the temperament file on your hard disk. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. Information about robert chuckrows book on historical tuning enables even those with.
Mean tone temperaments are constructed the same way as pythagorean tuning, as a stack of equal fifths, but in mea ntone each fifth is narrow compared to the perfect fifth of ratio 3. Pdf a clear and practical introduction to temperament history. This raises a major problem of wikipedia itself, the idea that anything published is a valid source. The problem is related to the meantone fifth that is. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols publications of the early music institute dolata, david on. With the correct amount of tempering, the syntonic comma is removed from its. In fact, it survived in pockets of resistance, especially in the tuning of english organs, all the way through the 19th century.
The latter were various kinds of meantone temperament. Ascending 5ths will be flatter than just, and descending 5ths will be sharper. In this system the perfect fifth is flattened by one quarter of a syntonic comma 81. In 1879, william pole wrote in his book the philosophy of music, the modern practice of tuning all organs to equal temperament has been a fearful detriment to their quality of tone. Pdf the use of meantone temperament in the performance of. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app.
A table showing a comparison of one meantone temperament with equal temperament can be found here. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols david dolata. Trying out meantone temperament in f minor youtube. One of the true pioneers in the history of temperament was pietro aron, who described the meantone temperament in 1523. Project muse meantone temperaments on lutes and viols. Meantone is best suited for the performance of early music on the harpsichord or organ. A schismatic temperament is a musical tuning system that results from tempering the schisma of 32805. I tuned my harpsichord to a415 as well as quarter comma meantone temperament.
Lindley, one of the top modern scholars in musical temperament. The shaping of harmony a brief history of temperament in western civilization by adam ahuja the modern quantum physicist finds himself in a moment of imperfection when studying particle physics. The result of this procedure is a scale with 8 pure major 3rds and 4 diminished 4ths. Historical developments are central to discussions of temperament because the music of the time is tied to the temperament of the time. During the meantone era that temperament was simply called the ordinary method of tuning keyboard instruments. No other tuning has survived in the west for 400 years. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols book depository. Melodically, this interval is very frequently used, and is of particular importance in cadences. Has anyone read the book how equal temperament ruined. Tuning and temperaments in the renaissance part ii duration. Meantone temperaments on lutes and viols written for musicians by a musician, meantone temperaments on lutes and viols demystifies tuning systems by providing the basic information, historical context, and practical advice necessary to easily achieve more satisfying tuning results on fretted instruments. Meantone temperament, in which you have pure thirds, is especially good. In the case of equal temperament each semitone has 100 cents. It is the 8th prime edo, following 17edo and coming before 23edo history.
1342 1095 655 136 251 961 1274 686 141 969 112 1479 909 577 586 746 1339 1265 1010 555 1037 1059 1574 1175 1468 1062 1511 930 90 706 553 583 1109 600 956 1363 901 1129 1486 259 530 1316 1312 1203 1184 459 1121 1429 1255